February 4, 2019 | Power-to-heat-to-power

Ongoing study – can solar thermal power plants store surplus electricity from other renewable sources efficiently?

  • Sector coupling
  • Solar thermal power plants
  • Thermal storage of power from variable renewable energy sources, such as photovoltaics and wind power

Solar researchers at the German Aerospace Center (Deutsches Zentrum für Luft- und Raumfahrt; DLR) have investigated whether it is economically viable for a solar thermal power plant to convert excess photovoltaic and wind power into heat and store it. Heat can be stored more cost-effectively than electricity, and can be recovered from the storage system as required in order to generate electricity.

By their very nature, sunlight and wind, as renewable sources of energy, fluctuate in intensity. Intelligent power grids and energy storage systems are essential in order to compensate for these fluctuations and ensure a secure supply of power from renewable energy sources.

Energy storage solutions are required to address the need for load balancing. This is the generating capacity that electricity suppliers must keep in reserve in order to cover peak demand. The second important function of such storage systems is the stabilisation of the grid voltage. Since power grids cannot store electrical energy, the power that is drawn out must be the same as the amount of power fed into the grid at all times. If more power enters the grid than is required or more electricity is drawn out than fed in, compensatory measures are required to stabilise the grid voltage.

Thermal storage as a buffer for power generation

One such possibility is using batteries to store surplus power. At present, however, sufficiently large batteries with the ability to cost effectively store the excess power produced by photovoltaic power plants and wind farms are not available. In order to maintain the balance between power supply and demand, operators of photovoltaic power plants and wind farms reduce their electricity output at times when there is plenty of sunshine or wind but low demand. Some of the existing energy generating potential thus remains untapped.

Unlike photovoltaic power plants, solar thermal power plants do not obtain their power directly from solar radiation. They concentrate the incident radiation using special mirrors in order to convert it into heat. As a result, temperatures in solar tower power plants can reach 1000 degrees Celsius. Only in the power generation section of the facility is the heat converted into electrical power using a turbine and a generator.

If a thermal storage system is integrated into the power plant, it can store some of the high-temperature heat produced for electricity generation for up to 18 hours. A solar thermal power plant can thus meet the power demand at a later time with energy from a renewable source, or have heat ready to use as load balancing power to compensate for fluctuations in the power grid. Due to the fluctuations in solar radiation and variable electricity demand, thermal storage facilities at solar power plants are not being fully utilised.

Using spare thermal storage capacity

The locations selected for solar thermal power plants usually offer very good conditions for photovoltaic power plants and wind farms. DLR solar researchers are looking into whether it makes sense – from both technological and economic points of view – to load the spare capacity in existing thermal storage systems with heat energy from excess photovoltaic and wind power.

As part of their investigations, the scientists simulated several power plant scenarios featuring integrated salt storage and connected electrical heaters to convert excess power into heat. They showed that variations in solar field dimensions, storage capacity and the number of heaters used affected the system layout and the resulting electricity generation costs to different degrees.

Up to 25 percent possible cost benefit for solar thermal power plants

The economic viability of the combined system is strongly dependent on the costs at which the solar tower power plant can obtain the surplus power. If it is cheaper than 3.5 eurocents per kilowatt hour, the average electricity generation costs of the solar power plant will fall as a result of the 'power-to-heat' input to the salt storage system. If the surplus power is available at zero cost, the solar tower power plant can feed electricity into the power grid at prices up to 25 percent lower than a comparable power plant without 'power-to-heat-to-power' components.

The interesting thing about this technology is that existing solar thermal power plants with high-temperature storage, for instance in Spain, can be retrofitted for power-to-heat-to-power conversion at a manageable cost. When planning future solar thermal power plants, the enhanced technology can be integrated during the design phase and optimised to suit the plant in question.

The techno-economic study was conducted as part of the DLR's IsEn strategy project, which began in January 2017. The DLR Institute of Engineering Thermodynamics coordinates the IsEn project. It involves scientists working in the fields of process systems engineering, electrochemical energy technology and thermal process technology at the DLR institutes of Engineering Thermodynamics, Propulsion Technology, Solar Research and Flight Systems. They are investigating 'power-to-X-to-power storage systems' in a number of different subprojects. Such storage systems convert electrical power into thermal, mechanical or chemical energy and can convert that energy back into electrical power at a later time. One of the researchers' key objectives is to minimise energy losses during conversion.


Michel Winand

Corporate Communications Aachen, Bonn, Cologne, Jülich, Rheinbach and Sankt Augustin
German Aerospace Center (DLR)
Corporate Communications
Linder Höhe, 51147 Cologne
Tel: +49 2203 601-2144

Stefano Giuliano

German Aerospace Center (DLR)
Institute of Solar Research
Linder Höhe, 51147 Cologne

Elke Reuschenbach

Head of Public Relations
German Aerospace Center (DLR)
Institute of Solar Research
Linder Höhe, 51147 Cologne

Dan Bauer

German Aerospace Center (DLR)
Institute of Engineering Thermodynamics
Pfaffenwaldring 38-40, 70569 Stuttgart