12. January 2018

NASA and DLR in­ves­ti­gate the im­pact of avi­a­tion on the cli­mate - joint flight tests on al­ter­na­tive fu­el emis­sions

Flying behind the A320 ATRA with the Falcon
Fly­ing be­hind the A320 ATRA with the Fal­con
Image 1/3, Credit: DLR (CC BY-NC-ND 3.0)

Flying behind the A320 ATRA with the Falcon

For these ex­per­i­ments with al­ter­na­tive fu­els, two DLR re­search air­craft flew at a typ­i­cal cruis­ing al­ti­tude of be­tween nine and twelve kilo­me­tres, one be­hind the oth­er in for­ma­tion, in a spe­cial­ly re­strict­ed airspace. Lead­ing the for­ma­tion is the A320 ATRA, close­ly fol­lowed by the DLR Fal­con.
NASA DC-8 be­fore a test flight
Image 2/3, Credit: DLR (CC-BY 3.0).

NASA DC-8 before a test flight

Dur­ing the re­search flights, the four CFM56 en­gines of the DC-8 al­ter­nat­ed be­tween reg­u­lar JP-8 jet fu­el and a one-to-one mix­ture of JP-8 and the bio­fu­el HEFA (Hy­dropro­cessed Es­ters and Fat­ty Acids). HEFA is ob­tained from the oil of Cameli­na plants.
DLR ATRA research aircraft
DLR ATRA re­search air­craft
Image 3/3, Credit: DLR/Evi Blink (CC-BY 3.0).

DLR ATRA research aircraft

The Air­bus A320-232 'D-ATRA' (Ad­vanced Tech­nol­o­gy Re­search Air­craft) is the largest mem­ber of the DLR re­search fleet.

  • Three weeks of research flights from Ramstein Air Base
  • NASA DC-8 and DLR A320 ATRA fly together
  • The focus is on particle emissions of alternative fuels and their influence on cloud formation from contrails and thus their climate impact
  • Focus: aeronautics, climate research, alternative fuels

In January 2018, the German Aerospace Center (Deutsches Zentrum für Luft- und Raumfahrt, DLR) and the US National Aeronautics and Space Administration (NASA) are set to conduct joint research flights in Germany for the first time. The focus will be on alternative fuel emissions and the characterisation of ice crystals in condensation trails (contrails), using biofuel as an example. The first joint DLR/NASA flights, which were conducted from Palmdale, California in 2014, showed that adding 50 percent alternative fuel for cruising flight reduces the soot particle emissions of an aircraft engine by 50 to 70 percent, compared to the combustion of pure kerosene. The planned research flights are intended to determine particle emissions and how they affect cloud formation through contrails, thus investigating their impact on the climate. From 14 January 2018, NASA's DC-8 re­search air­craft will visit Germany for three weeks and fly together with the DLR A320 Advanced Technology Research Aircraft (ATRA). "We are delighted that NASA has chosen us as their partner for such an extensive joint mission in Germany," says Rolf Henke, DLR Executive Board member responsible for aeronautics research. The research flights will start from Ramstein Air Base.

"NASA could not do this alone. We're bringing the two agencies together to combine resources and facilities to study alternative fuels in an unprecedented way," said Bruce Anderson, NASA's principal investigator for this latest phase of airborne research. The joint research flight campaign has been given the title ND-MAX/ECLIF 2 (NASA/DLR-Multidisciplinary Airborne eXperiments/Emission and CLimate Impact of alternative Fuel).

For the international research mission, the DLR A320 ATRA will fly using various fuel blends, while NASA’s fully instrumented DC-8 'flying laboratory' will follow at a safe distance, measuring soot particles, gas emissions and ice crystals in ATRA's exhaust gas stream. Numerous DLR measuring instruments have been installed on board the NASA aircraft for this purpose. "We have installed instruments on board the DC8 to simultaneously measure the size distribution of soot and ice particles and gas emissions as it follows in the wake of ATRA," reports Hans Schlager from the DLR In­sti­tute of At­mo­spher­ic Physics. "The focus of our measurements is to characterise the emissions produced using different fuel blends. We are particularly interested in finding out how the soot emissions of the different fuels affect the radiation properties and lifetime of the contrails."

Preparations in California

Several DLR scientists and engineers are currently installing the measuring equipment aboard the DC-8 at its home base – NASA's Armstrong Flight Research Center in California. At the same time, preparations are underway at the NATO Air Base in Ramstein, Rhineland-Palatinate (south-western Germany), from where the research flights will take off in the second half of January. "We are currently in the process of delivering the fuels that have been specially produced for these test flights," says André Krajewski from the DLR In­sti­tute of Com­bus­tion Tech­nol­o­gy. "We have created fuel blends that contain 30 to 50 percent Hydroprocessed Esters and Fatty Acids (HEFA), which will be used in a total of eight planned joint research flights." The HEFA biofuel selected for these trials is largely derived from the oil of Camelina plants, representative of alternative fuels, which could also be synthetic.

In addition to the emissions, the international research team is interested in how the different fuel blends affect the performance of the engines. "Biofuels such as HEFA differ in their composition from conventional kerosene in that they are pure paraffins and contain no cyclic hydrocarbons. When mixed with conventional jet A-1 kerosene, one obtains an approved fuel.” explains Patrick Le Clercq of the DLR In­sti­tute of Com­bus­tion Tech­nol­o­gy. "The modified fuel composition has an impact on the formation of soot during combustion."

Previous joint research flights

In recent years, several research campaigns into alternative fuels have been conducted in the United States and Germany under different meteorological conditions. Earlier NASA-led research campaigns, called ACCESS I and II (Alternative Fuel Effects on Contrails and Cruise Emissions), were carried out in California in 2013 and 2014. During these campaigns, NASA's DC-8 flew with alternative fuels, while smaller research jets such as the NASA HU-25 Falcon and the DLR Falcon 20 conducted measurements in its exhaust stream. The ECLIF campaign followed in 2015 and was led by DLR in Germany, with the involvement of a number of NASA researchers. In this campaign, the DLR A320 ATRA flew with alternative fuels, while the DLR Falcon 20, equipped with instruments, followed behind, carrying out measurements of the emissions and contrails. In addition, extensive emissions readings were carried out from the ground.

Previous results from research flights have shown a significant reduction in soot particles when alternative fuels are used and suggest that this also leads to a lower quantity of ice crystals in contrails. "Lower soot emissions from these alternative fuels are good news for the environment, and it would be even better if the flight tests confirm that using alternative fuels also reduces the number of ice crystals in contrails," says NASA's Bruce Anderson. DLR researcher Hans Schlager adds: "This is a significant issue because contrails and the cirrus clouds that are formed as a result are thought to have a greater warming effect on Earth's atmosphere than the total carbon dioxide emissions that have accumulated as a result of air travel over the last century or more." Contrails contain many small ice particles that form due to the condensation of water vapour on the soot particles in aircraft exhaust gases. Contrails can linger for several hours in humid, cold conditions at altitudes of between eight and 12 kilometres, forming high-level clouds called contrail cirrus. Depending on the position of the Sun and the ground, these clouds can have a local warming or cooling effect. Knowledge of this is essential for assessing the climate impact of aviation. The research conducted thus far suggests that a warming effect is predominant globally.

Favourable meteorological conditions in Germany

The winter meteorological conditions in Germany are favourable for the upcoming DLR/NASA flights and the planned measurement of ice crystals in contrails. The use of the DLR A320 ATRA as a 'source of emissions' and the NASA DC-8 as a measuring platform will allow the researchers to conduct their flight tests at the altitude and usual cruising speed of passenger jets, under which conditions contrails typically form. To this end, the researchers have installed the most extensive range of measuring equipment ever employed for such investigations in the DC-8, with half of the measuring devices provided by the DLR Institute of Atmospheric Physics.

If everything runs smoothly with the final preparations for the joint research flight campaign, the first joint flight test will take place on 16 January 2018. A total of 80 flight hours for taking measurements are planned between then and 2 February.

Proven collaboration

DLR and NASA have been working together in the field of atmospheric research for 19 years. In aeronautics research, both partners are particularly involved in joint research projects relating to air traffic management and flying that generates low noise and emissions.

  • Falk Dambowsky
    Ger­man Aerospace Cen­ter (DLR)

    Com­mu­ni­ca­tions and Me­dia Re­la­tions
    Telephone: +49 2203 601-3959
    Linder Höhe
    51147 Cologne
  • Dr Hans Schlager
    Ger­man Aerospace Cen­ter (DLR)
    In­sti­tute of At­mo­spher­ic Physics
    In­sti­tute of At­mo­spher­ic Physics
    Telephone: +49 8153 28-2510
    Fax: +49 8153 28-1841
    Münchener Straße 20
    82234 Oberpfaffenhofen
  • Patrick Le Clercq
    Head of De­part­ment Mul­ti­phase Flow and Al­ter­na­tive Fu­els
    Ger­man Aerospace Cen­ter (DLR)
    In­sti­tute of Com­bus­tion Tech­nol­o­gy
    Telephone: +49 711 6862-441
    Fax: +49 711 6862-578
    Pfaffenwaldring 38-40
    70569 Stuttgart
  • André Krajewski
    Ger­man Aerospace Cen­ter (DLR)

    DLR Flight Ex­per­i­ments Fa­cil­i­ty
    Telephone: +49 531 295-2866
    Linder Höhe
    51147 Köln
  • Kate Squires
    Na­tion­al Aero­nau­tics and Space Ad­min­is­tra­tion (NASA)

    Arm­strong Flight Re­search Cen­ter
    Telephone: +1 661 276-2020

  • Sandra Archer
    86th Air­lift Wing

    Pub­lic Af­fairs Of­fice Ram­stein Air Base
    Telephone: +49 6371 47-2458


Main menu